Roast chicken first
"You could probably get through life without knowing how to roast a chicken, but the question is would you want to?" Nigella Lawson

First because this is a first recipe from NIgella's first book - now a classic - How to Eat. Lots of words, not a single picture, and no recipe headings really - just a sort of heading in the margins in capital letters. It's also quite a big book. I don't know whether it exists in a hardback edition. Mine is this Vintage version from Penguin complete with an introduction by Jeanette Winterson - a renowned lesbian novelist which is an interesting choice. Maybe she is also a keen cook, or a friend of Nigella, and her introduction is certainly fulsome, and with many pertinent - for me anyway - points to make:
"A recipe though is a list of ingredients and the method of combining them. Recipes are like plot summaries of Shakespeare's plays; we know what's supposed to happen the real pleasure is in the writing.
And it is the same with a classic cookbook. What makes our mouths water when we read a cookbook isn't the food on the table; it's the story about the food on the table."
Which is particularly true of cookbooks with no pictures, and one of the reasons why we all loved Elizabeth David. She evoked landscapes and cultures we all dreamed of visiting, and she had personality - even if it was somewhat abrasive at times. Today it's why I love Nigel - he writes so well, Ottolenghi too, or maybe that's Tara Wigley - I'm never sure who does the writing in the cookbooks. Ottolenghi in the Introduction perhaps and Tara Wigley for the rest. And have you noticed an increasing number of cookbooks which emphasise stories and which have introductions to each recipe?
Jeanette Winterson goes on to say:
"The classic cookbook is different. The classic cookbook is practical, for sure, but it's more than a how-to. Nigella calls her recipes, 'a reminder of possibilities'."
Nigella herself, in her, original Preface tells us that the book is called How to Eat, not How to Cook because:
"although it's possible to love eating without being able to cook, I don't believe you can ever really cook unless you love eating. ...
Our gastronomic awakening - or however, and with whatever degree of irony, you want to describe it - has been to a huge extent restaurant-led. It is, you might argue, by tasting food that we have become interested in cooking it."

Not that she tells you how to eat her basic roast chicken and there is no picture of course, so I pinched this one of a classic poulet rôti from The Food of France, on which hers is loosely based.
Herewith I diverge slightly to say that of course we had roast chicken at home as a child - it would have been the cheapest meat to roast, but there would have been no butter. It was probably cooked with dripping as the fatty element, served with roast potatoes and boiled cabbage. And gravy of course. But we loved it nevertheless. However, when I went to France it was yet another cooking revelation. All that butter - and French butter at that. We just don't make butter like the French. And fundamentally that's what the French do - slather the chicken with butter - inside and out - and cook it.

Nigella's basic chicken recipe "is the same as my mother's" and it is just a few lines:
"I stick half a lemon up its bottom, smear some oil or butter on its breast, sprinkle it with a little salt, and put in a gas mark6/200ºC oven for about 20 minutes per 500g plus 30 minutes."
Which led the writer of the My Favourite Plum blog, whose picture of her go at Nigella's infamous roast chicken recipe is above, to say:
"Sometimes women in twin sets do know what they're suggestively suggesting ... and the sauce is absolutely delicious." My Favourite Plum
She also followed Nigella's advice and roasted two chickens at the same time, so that she had a leftover one with which to try other 'possibilities' in the week following.
Nigella also digressed by saying that:
"My mother could make the stringiest, toughest flesh - a bird that had been intensively farmed and frozen since the last Ice Age - taste as if it were a lovingly reared poulet de Bresse. She, you see, was the product of her age, which believed that cooking lay in what you did to inferior products ... I, however, am a product of mine, which believes that always use the best, the freshest produce of the highest quality you can afford - and then do as little as possible to it."
But she does say that: "I can't honestly say that my roast chicken tastes better than hers"
Although she does add that:
"If you know you've got an inferior bird in front of you, cook it for the first hour breast side down. This means that you don't, at the end, have quite that glorious effect of the swelling burnished breast - the chicken will have more of a flapper's bosom, flat but fleshy - but the white meat will be more tender because all the fats and juices will have oozed their way into it."

Which is a method that Elizabeth David uses for her Chicken with tarragon, the recipe for which can be found on The Spice Garden website, and about which the writer of the piece on this recipe says:
"A rustic French treatment for a small chicken ... only six ingredients, a piece of jute string, and a hot oven."
The six ingredients are your chicken, butter, tarragon, garlic, salt and pepper, brandy - which is seven - although perhaps salt and pepper count as one. The brandy is flamed and poured over the chicken at the end - a rather fancy addition for a simple peasant dish.
Also at the end of her recipe Elizabeth David says:
"At this moment (when you are adding the brandy) you can, if you like, enrich the sauce with a few spoonfuls of thick cream and, at La Mère Michel's Paris restaurant, from where the recipe originally came, they add Madeira to the sauce. Good though this is, it seems to me a needless complication."
Such an Elizabeth David comment don't you think?

Back in England Nigel Slater says of his Roast chicken with roast potatoes and roasting juices that:
"A good bird, the thoughtfully seasoned pan juices and a roast potato or three is more than enough. ...
The point of a roast chicken is not only the meat, the golden skin, the roast potatoes that surround it, but also what collects in the pan while it cooks. The sticky goo, the encrusted bits and bobs, the sweet, salty juices and glossy morsels that adhere to the roasting tin."
Note that he, like Nigella is of his time, in the emphasis on a 'good bird'.
I could not, of course, do a post on Basic roast chicken without referring to Simon Hopkinson and Lindsey Bareham's book Roast Chicken and Other Stories - again - the reference to stories. On which, I have to say, that my book The Food of France, gloriously photographed as it is, has no stories - just a few short pages about the regions of France. Simon Hopkinson's book has some attractive drawings/paintings at the head of each chapter, but no illustrations of the food.
He also has more or less the same opinion as Nigella on the quality of the chicken itself, although he is rather more definite:
A good cook can produce a good dish from any old scrawnbag of a chook. A poor cook will produce a poor dish - even from a Bresse chicken. I firmly believe this to be true."

Then we get a glimpse of why the title of the book when he says:
"Roasting a chicken is a joy for me; and if I am pressed to name my favourite food, then roast chicken it must be."
His recipe for Roast chicken can be found on The Guardian website. It is much the same as the other French ones - lots of butter, lemon, tarragon, garlic ... so that:
"What you end up with in the tin is an amalgamation of butter, lemon juice and chicken juices. That's all. It is a perfect homogenisation of fats and liquids. All it needs is a light whisk or a stir and you have the most wonderful gravy imaginable. If you wish to add extra flavour, you can scoop the garlic and herbs out of the chicken cavity, stir them into the gravy and heat through; strain before serving."
So what do the current generation of cooks have to say on the matter? Perhaps what is most interesting is that almost all of them have something to say somewhere, some at greater length than others, but as Alison Roman says in her one page essay on roast chicken:
"Probably one of the most asked questions in the world of home cooking is: How do I make a great roast chicken?"
And they will all have one recipe - probably several - Nigella certainly now has several. And they take it very seriously. Alison Roman goes on to say:

"Perfectly roasting a chicken is a meditation, a practice, a lifelong pursuit. Each time I do it, I'm trying to best myself, and even if I don't, I end up with something pretty remarkable." This is the attitude I wish for you to have. 'Perfections is not the goal' is what I want you to repeat as the bird slides into the oven. 'It's the journey, not the destination,' you'll say as you smell the chicken fat dripping off, the skin browning alongside something wonderful like skinny leeks or cloves of smashed garlic, already so pleased with yourself (and your chicken)."
And that is the Crisp, hot roast chicken with leeks she refers to above. For that's what the modern cooks tend to do - add something else into the mix - because it's fun I suppose - and because the basic roast chicken has been done and dusted so many times by big names in food, that it's probably not worth doing your own.
"The beauty of a roast chicken – and how I have come to think of it as a ‘pantry meal’ – is that you can (and I will!) add anything you have on hand to the skillet to roast alongside it." Alison Roman
The other thing that is often done today is spatchcocking your chicken, whereby you cut your chicken along the backbone and then flatten it. Because:
"I spatchcocked a plump free-ranger this week, flattening the bird out just to cut its cooking time down and saved on heat and temper." Nigel Slater
And herewith a few examples - to end this longer than I thought it would be, post - the first from Nigel himself - Spatchcocked chicken with rocket couscous; Roast chicken curry with crispy curry leaves - Ixta Belfrage/The Meat Room - I guess not technically a roast chicken because of the large amount of sauce, but interesting; Loomi lemon chicken - Noor Murad/The Gloss; Roast chicken with cabbage and soy butter - Yotam Ottolengh and Verena Lochmuller
Very different from basic roast chicken I know, but it demonstrates how methods and ideas evolve over time. At an ever-quickening pace it seems. Maybe I'll have a go at Nigella's version just as a reminder of those dreamy roast chickens of France.
YEARS GONE BY
November 14
2025 - Chestnuts
2021 - Missing
2020 - Missing
2019 - Nothing
2018 - What is it with bowls?
2017 - The vanilla slice
2016 - Vegeta - what's that?



I don't remember roast chicken in my early childhood, more the stewed chicken and stewed lamb. Perhaps becasue my father (who did most of the cooking) learnt to cook in France on the Western Front of World War 1 - where he worked in a kitchen behind the front line. "In the Western Front during World War I cooking was split between large-scale field kitchens behind the lines and improvised heating in the front-line trenches". That's how he survied to father his three children born in the middle of WW11. No ovens just bif pots! 😇